Medicare Under Siege: The Coalition’s Attacks vs. Labor’s Bulk Billing Boost

A Tale of Two Approaches to Healthcare

In Australia, access to universal healthcare is a cornerstone of national identity. Medicare, the system that ensures all Australians can receive medical treatment without crippling financial burdens, has long been a political battleground. The contrast between the Coalition’s systematic attempts to undermine Medicare and Labor’s newly announced boost to bulk billing could not be starker.

As the Albanese government moves to strengthen Medicare with a massive increase in bulk billing incentives, it’s crucial to examine the Coalition’s historical attempts to erode the system—through funding cuts, privatisation pushes, the introduction of private health insurance penalties like the Medicare Levy Surcharge (MLS) and Lifetime Health Cover (LHC) loading, and increased out-of-pocket costs for Australians.

---

The Coalition’s Attacks on Medicare: A Decade of Undermining Universal Healthcare

Since the Abbott government took office in 2013, the Liberal-National Coalition has consistently sought to reduce Medicare’s effectiveness, often under the guise of “efficiency” or “budget repair.” However, these attacks on Medicare did not begin in 2013, but date back decades, with significant changes implemented under the Howard Government.

1. The Introduction of the Medicare Levy Surcharge (1997) and Lifetime Health Cover Loading (2000)

While Medicare was originally designed to be a universal healthcare system, the Howard government introduced policies aimed at shifting Australians towards private health insurance.

• Medicare Levy Surcharge (MLS) – Introduced in 1997: A tax penalty on higher-income earners who do not purchase private hospital cover, designed to coerce wealthier Australians into private insurance rather than rely on Medicare.
• Lifetime Health Cover (LHC) – Introduced in 2000: A 2% per year surcharge on private health insurance premiums for anyone who does not take out private hospital cover before age 30. This effectively penalised Australians for choosing to rely on Medicare and pressured young people into taking up policies they might not need.

These policies pushed Australians into private health insurance and effectively undermined the universality of Medicare by increasing the financial burden on those who remained in the public system.

2. The 2014 $7 GP Co-Payment Proposal

One of the most notorious attacks on Medicare came in Joe Hockey’s 2014 Budget, where the Coalition proposed a $7 co-payment for GP visits. This move was widely criticised as an attack on the most vulnerable Australians, including pensioners and low-income families. The plan was ultimately scrapped due to public outcry, but it signalled the Coalition’s intent to shift healthcare costs onto individuals.

3. The Medicare Freeze (2014–2020)

Another significant attack was the Medicare rebate freeze, which spanned six years. By refusing to index Medicare rebates to inflation, the Coalition forced GPs to absorb rising costs or pass them onto patients. This led to:

• Higher out-of-pocket costs for GP visits.
• A decline in the number of doctors offering bulk billing.
• Increased pressure on hospital emergency departments as patients avoided costly GP consultations.

4. The Push for Privatisation

Under Malcolm Turnbull, there were secret plans to privatise Medicare’s payment system, a move that sparked national outrage. The 2016 federal election saw Labor successfully weaponise the issue, with its “Medicare is at risk” campaign forcing Turnbull to abandon the proposal.

5. Morrison’s Further Cuts and Bulk Billing Decline

Under Scott Morrison, bulk billing rates began to decline rapidly, with fewer GPs able to afford offering fully subsidised consultations. Meanwhile, the government made further cuts to pathology and diagnostic imaging rebates, increasing costs for patients requiring essential tests.

---

Labor’s Medicare Boost: Rebuilding Universal Healthcare

In contrast to the Coalition’s attempts to hollow out Medicare, the Albanese government has announced a historic boost to bulk billing, aimed at reversing years of damage and ensuring that vulnerable Australians can once again access free GP visits.

1. The $3.5 Billion Bulk Billing Incentive Increase

Labor’s plan includes:

• Tripling bulk billing incentives for GPs treating children, pensioners, and concession card holders.
• A $3.5 billion investment to ensure more doctors can afford to bulk bill patients.
• Funding to expand Medicare Urgent Care Clinics, reducing pressure on emergency departments.

2. Addressing GP Shortages and Medical Workforce Issues

Recognising the struggles facing GPs, Labor’s policy includes increased funding for medical training and rural healthcare incentives, ensuring that Medicare remains viable across all regions of Australia.

3. Making Medicines Cheaper

Labor has also introduced policies to cut prescription costs, making common medicines more affordable and reducing overall healthcare expenses for everyday Australians.

---

The Verdict: A Stark Choice for Voters

The upcoming election will once again put Medicare front and centre. The Coalition’s record is clear—they have spent decades chipping away at universal healthcare, increasing costs for individuals, and pushing Australians into private health insurance with punitive surcharges and tax penalties. In contrast, the Albanese government’s reforms represent the most significant strengthening of Medicare in decades.

The choice is simple:

• A government that invests in Medicare and ensures bulk billing remains accessible.
• Or a Coalition that has a proven track record of cutting, freezing, and privatising public healthcare.

For many Australians, the difference could mean access to affordable healthcare—or being forced to skip GP visits due to cost.

Source List:

1. 2014 Federal Budget – https://archive.budget.gov.au/2014-15/
2. Australian Medical Association (AMA) on Medicare Freeze – https://www.ama.com.au/media/medicare-freeze-hurting-patients-and-doctors
3. The Guardian on Medicare Privatisation Plan – https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2016/jun/19/turnbull-government-admits-it-has-medicare-privatisation-taskforce
4. ABC News on Bulk Billing Decline – https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-25/medicare-bulk-billing-rates-fall/100237236
5. Australian Government – Labor’s Bulk Billing Boost – https://www.health.gov.au/resources/publications/bulk-billing-incentive-tripling-announcement
6. The Conversation on Medicare Changes – https://theconversation.com/australias-medicare-system-explained-and-the-urgent-need-for-reform-185532
7. Treasury on Medicare Levy Surcharge – https://treasury.gov.au/tax-policy/tax-and-transfer-policy/medicare-levy-surcharge
8. Australian Government on Lifetime Health Cover – https://www.privatehealth.gov.au/health_insurance/surcharges_incentives/lifetime_health_cover.htm